The first point is that I do not believe in sentimental caps for anyone, even if, like Ben Youngs, you are on 99 and there is only one to go to make you a centurion. You are picked on merit and current form – not past form – and you should be the best player to help England win their next match.
That means starting Ben Spencer at scrum-half against Italy in the final match of the Six Nations in Rome, with Dan Robson on the bench.
Spencer has been on fire since joining Bath, and is currently not only the best scrum-half in England, but one of the best in the world, while Robson’s form for Wasps, has also been very impressive.
Ben Youngs is a lovely guy, and as an ex-scrum-half who has coached him, I know that when ex-players are critical it does have an impact – so this pains me. However, I’m here to give an opinion, and mine is that it is time for new blood in the England No.9 shirt.
When I look at the Top 5 English scrum-halves in the Premiership since the 2019 World Cup, Youngs does not get into it. My rankings are: 1 Ben Spencer 2 Dan Robson 3 Danny Care 4= Alex Mitchell and Harry Randall.
What’s more he only just scrapes into the Top 10 after you include the overseas scrum-halves. Those rankings read: 1 Ben Spencer (Bath) 2 Dan Robson (Wasps) 3 Danny Care (Harlequins) 4 Faf de Klerk (Sale) 5 Martin Landajo (Harlequins) 6 François Hougaard (Worcester) 7 Nick Phipps (London Irish) 8= Alex Mitchell (Northampton), Harry Randall (Bristol) 10 Ben Youngs (Leicester).
To be playing for your country you should be the best – and when he first came on the England scene it was a claim Youngs could make, because he was very good.
This story is from the September 20, 2020 edition of The Rugby Paper.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the September 20, 2020 edition of The Rugby Paper.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
I'm loving every single minute
IN THE picturesque town of Pau nestled at the foot of the Pyrenees, Joe Simmonds has found more than just a rugby club; he’s found a new place to call home.
Scoring in Hell Fire Comer was great
SEEING Scottie Scheffler being presented with the Green Jacket for winning golf’s US Masters last week reminded me of the time I was presented with a red one having played my 100th game for Redruth. It might not have the same kudos in the wider sporting world but, for me, it is a treasured item from my four years at the club.
Defeated, but Ukraine show grit and pride
SWITZERLAND was always going to be Ukraine’s toughest match of this three Test series and so it proved.
Crane: Sinckler's an emotional guy
JORDAN Crane feels England have failed to get the best out of Kyle Sinckler during his international career, with the tighthead prop set to be unavailable for his country from next season as he heads to the Top 14.
YOUNG GUNS
Newcastle Falcons have endured a dismal campaign in the Premiership but tyro hooker Jacob Oliver believes the future is bright in the North East as he hopes to follow fellow academy graduates by breaking into the first team.
Hurricanes storm in despite triple yellow
HURRICANES overcame a poor second half in which they conceded three yellow cards to beat Fijian Drua 38-15 and stretch their winning start to eight matches to end their opponent’s unbeaten record at home.
JIFF looks likely to play a vital role
IT’S LOGICAL – as the final stop-start sprint in a hard fought Top 14 season begins – to think purely in terms of matches remaining, points potential, and table possibilities. In fact, with play-off and Champions Cup places up for grabs, and relegation to avoid, such thoughts are not just logical, they’re inevitable.
S Africa is crying out for its own league
IF I remember my A level geography correctly, Africa is moving towards Europe at about the same rate as your fingernails grow which, among other things, suggests that the wholesale, no holds barred, in for a penny in for a pound merging of British, European and South African rugby was a tad premature.
Lion who enjoyed a taste of Italy
ANDREA Gazzi’s grave lies on the Inner Hebridean island of Islay, a long way from the fish-and-chip shop he left behind in Gorseinon.
Furbank: We were spoonfed too much
GEORGE Furbank feels Northampton’s rise this season is down to a pre-season meeting when the players resolved to take more responsibility.
