Judicial activism could upset the separation of powers and affect the dignity of the judiciary, as orders are either being ignored or proving to be unimplementable.
A few months ago, sparks flew in the Supreme Court when Attorney General K.K. Venugopal said some of the court’s decisions were adversely impacting governance, causing damage to the economy and making people lose their livelihoods. “Not everything is negative, but the court should exercise restraint while dealing with public interest litigations,” Venugopal told a bench headed by Justice Madan B. Lokur, which was hearing a petition on the condition of prison inmates.
Lokur, a specialist on PILs pertaining to social justice, responded, “Through orders of this court, you have got thousands of crores in cases like mining, construction work. What more do we do? Rest assured that Article 21 [right to life and liberty] is here to stay and we will uphold it.”
The debate had been set off by a suggestion from the bench that a committee headed by a former Supreme Court judge be set up to monitor prison reforms. The government counsel called it an attempt by the court to indulge in policy-making, a domain of the executive. The bench, however, did form a panel headed by retired justice Amitava Roy for the purpose.
Lokur was again at the centre of a heated debate as a two-judge bench headed by him ruled that in view of air pollution assuming dangerous proportions, only ‘green’ crackers be burst during Diwali, and also restricted the time for fireworks to two hours. While environment-conscious quarters welcomed the order, there was immense criticism of the decision, and judiciary watchers wondered whether it would not have been better for the court to direct the government to take necessary measures. “It would have been wiser to direct the government to resort to such steps as were necessary to minimise pollution,” said former Supreme Court judge K.T. Thomas.
This story is from the December 02, 2018 edition of THE WEEK.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the December 02, 2018 edition of THE WEEK.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
BIOPIC AND BEYOND
Randeep Hooda may have proved his acting credentials with biopics, but typecast him at your own peril
Flutter of flimsy wings
Butterfly Research Centre in Bhimtal boasts 3,500 butterfly and moth specimens
SIMILAR STATES, DIFFERENT BATTLES
The Congress seems to have the edge in Telangana while in Andhra Pradesh, Chandrababu Naidu and Jagan Mohan Reddy are locked in a bitter battle
A RIDE TO REMEMBER
On board Andhra Pradesh Chief Minister Y.S. Jagan Mohan Reddy’s bus as he was attacked
Winning 14 of 17 seats is my target
Anumula Revanth Reddy is on a mission to demonstrate a democratic and egalitarian facet of power and leadership.
LOTUS TAKES ROOT
Buoyed by its slowly growing acceptance among the voters in Tamil Nadu, the BJP is mounting its fiercest offensive ever
BLANK CHECK
Several factors favour an increase in the BJP’s vote share in Kerala, but whether the party can win a seat remains uncertain
CONGRESS HAS A HISTORY OF MAKING ADJUSTMENTS WITH COMMUNAL FORCES
In April 2021, as Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan was leading the CPI(M)’s assembly poll campaign to win a second consecutive term, a spirited debate erupted in Kerala over an epithet that party workers had bestowed on him.
POLL PLOT
Congress hopes its five guarantees’ will blunt BJP’s aggressive push
MODI'S GUARANTEES REMAIN IN SPEECHES, MY GUARANTEES ARE FULFILLED
The transformation is unmissable. The old-school mass leader Siddaramaiah has suddenly switched into the new avatar of a master strategist.