Property & Plagiarism
Noseweek|February 2019
Property & Plagiarism

Developer Tongaat-Hulett under fire for blatantly using another firm’s plans.

Jonathan Erasmus

DID TONGAAT-HULETT’S PROPERTY arm steal architectural draw-ings which were then used to raise capital from the Depart-ment of Trade and Industry for a luxury property development, from a trusting small consortium of KwaZulu-Natal businessmen?

If so, it fits neatly with the ugly truth about corporate South Africa’s tendency to steal ideas from small businesses. Noseweek has carried many such stories, from the “Please Call Me” vs Vodacom scandal (nose200), to Standard Bank being accused of clandestinely copying keypad software (nose204) to Foschini Group copying a unique bread-bin design and when caught, offering a paltry R30,000 to the Cape Town-based kitchen design studio (nose214).

Ballito-based Sugarland Resorts and Development (Pty) Ltd is convinced KwaZulu-Natal’s largest private property owner and developer, Tongaat-Hulett Developments (Pty) Ltd, used their intellectual property to sell a luxury estate plan to both local and national government, and convince Kuwaiti-based hotel developers, IFA, to come on board, to construct Zimbali Lakes, a R10-billion project on KwaZulu-Natal’s North Coast.

The Zimbali franchise just outside Ballito is synonymous with luxury gated estate living, with its luxury private mansions and hotel often used as quiet getaways by the rich and famous. Former AU chairperson Nkosazana DlaminiZuma has a home in the estate while Robert Mugabe’s family are said to have stayed there too.

Sugarland Resorts and Development, led by Ballito resident Colin Mitchell who specialises in strategic planning, business and project feasibility studies, first approached Tongaat-Hulett Developments – then known as Moreland – in 1997/98 about an idea to build a luxury mixed-use development at the mouth of the uThongathi River, adjacent to the Zimbali Coastal Resort and Estate which was developed by Tongaat-Hulett more than 20 years ago. Mitchell’s project was named and referred to as Sugarland.

The idea was to include an artificially created lake adjacent to the river while homes would have panoramic sea views. Mitchell and his partners initially plowed about R250,000 in cash into various studies, including just how the lake would be built, as well as into architectural designs. Mitchell eventually even sold his home to fund the project.

The detailed master drawing revealed that Sugarland included luxury apartments, a hotel, a themed waterfront, a “Zulu village”, waterfront entertainment, nature trails and retail space.


You can read up to 3 premium stories before you subscribe to Magzter GOLD

Log in, if you are already a subscriber


Get unlimited access to thousands of curated premium stories, newspapers and 5,000+ magazines


February 2019