“If I wanted a sinecure for my judgments, why would I ask for just a Rajya Sabha seat?”
India Today|April 06, 2020
Former Chief Justice of India, RANJAN GOGOI, stirred controversy when—nominated by the President of India—he took oath as a Rajya Sabha MP on March 19, just four months after he had demitted office as the head of the Supreme Court of India. Opposition leaders and several jurists cried foul, charging that his nomination was effectively a quid pro quo from the Modi government, a reward for several verdicts during his tenure that allegedly favoured the government. In the first-ever interview of his career, Gogoi spoke exclusively to INDIA TODAY Group Editorial Director Raj Chengappa and Senior Editor Kaushik Deka. Excerpts:
Raj Chengappa and Senior Editor Kaushik Deka
“If I wanted a sinecure for my judgments, why would I ask for just a Rajya Sabha seat?”

Why did you accept the Rajya Sabha nomination so soon after demitting the office of the Chief Justice of India? Shouldn’t there have been a cooling-off period?

A. Why should I not have accepted it? When the president of the country makes an offer under Article 80, you don’t refuse it. When the nation wants your services, should you refuse that? As far as a cooling-off period is concerned, tell me, under what law or rule can the cooling-off period be visualised? If [it] is required, please make a law for [it]. Also, if a cooling-off period is applied, how do you [then] man the tribunals that have to be headed by retired Supreme Court judges? It is for the executive or the policymakers to prescribe a norm for cooling-off.

Q. In March 2019, you had said that post-retirement appointments are a blot on the independence of the judiciary. What changed?

A. Do you think a Rajya Sabha seat is a job? My statement was in the context of a judgment which dealt with tribunalisation. It’s not a job. It’s a recognition and an expectation that you will contribute in your field of expertise.

Q. When you were being sworn in, opposition parties walked off, crying ‘Shame!’. How do you react to that?

A. No reaction. It was expected. Opposition parties walk in and walk out. I don’t see how that can disturb any reasonable person.

Q. It’s not just opposition parties. Several former judges have suggested that your nomination was a sinecure for those verdicts during your tenure that favoured the Modi government—such as in the Ram Janmabhoomi case and the Rafale deal.

This story is from the April 06, 2020 edition of India Today.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.

This story is from the April 06, 2020 edition of India Today.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.

MORE STORIES FROM INDIA TODAYView All
Check On Sale Of Insurance
India Today

Check On Sale Of Insurance

Complaints about insurance mis-selling come up mostly when a claim is rejected or the policyholder doesn't get what he thinks he bought the policy for

time-read
4 mins  |
April 01, 2024
How To Make Better Financial Decisions
India Today

How To Make Better Financial Decisions

Let logic, not emotion, dictate your wealth choices. Understand your emotions first, then temper them with facts, and you will arrive at better financial decisions

time-read
10+ mins  |
April 01, 2024
WHEN DO YOU GET AN INCOME TAX REFUND?
India Today

WHEN DO YOU GET AN INCOME TAX REFUND?

An assessee becomes entitled to an income tax refund when the tax they have paid exceeds what they are liable to pay in a financial year

time-read
2 mins  |
April 01, 2024
STANDING UP AND TRANSFORMING LIVES
India Today

STANDING UP AND TRANSFORMING LIVES

THE LAUNCH EVENT OF THE MAHINDRA RISE INITIATIVE, ORGANISED BY THE INDIA TODAY GROUP AND MAHINDRA & MAHINDRA, HONOURED WOMEN TRAILBLAZERS WHO ARE LEADING THE CHARGE FOR A BETTER INDIA

time-read
3 mins  |
April 01, 2024
THE SENSE OF ARRIVAL
India Today

THE SENSE OF ARRIVAL

Samantha Ruth Prabhu's journey in the film industry has been about finding success by overcoming fear

time-read
1 min  |
April 01, 2024
IN THE SAFE ZONE
India Today

IN THE SAFE ZONE

AUTOMOTIVE COMPANIES ARE INCREASINGLY FOCUSSED ON BETTER AND MORE ADVANCED SAFETY FEATURES IN THEIR CARS. HEIGHTENED CUSTOMER AWARENESS HAS GIVEN THIS AN ADDED IMPETUS

time-read
4 mins  |
April 01, 2024
TWIN STRIKE
India Today

TWIN STRIKE

WE GET A LEG OVER APRILIA'S MADE-IN-INDIA RS 457 AT THE GRUELLING KARI MOTOR SPEEDWAY

time-read
2 mins  |
April 01, 2024
INDIAN SAFETY RATINGS FOR CARS
India Today

INDIAN SAFETY RATINGS FOR CARS

THE BHARAT NEW CAR ASSESSMENT PROGRAM RATES THEM FOR BOTH ADULT AND CHILD OCCUPANT PROTECTION

time-read
2 mins  |
April 01, 2024
THE MEDIUM, NOT THE MESSAGE
India Today

THE MEDIUM, NOT THE MESSAGE

We live in an age where there is an economy built on distraction and a complete corruption of attention.

time-read
3 mins  |
April 01, 2024
HAIL TO THE KING - THE HYUNDAI CRETA GETS MAJOR UPDATES, LOOKS SET TO CONTINUE AS SEGMENT LEADER
India Today

HAIL TO THE KING - THE HYUNDAI CRETA GETS MAJOR UPDATES, LOOKS SET TO CONTINUE AS SEGMENT LEADER

Just under four years after the arrival of the second generation Creta, Hyundai has given its bestseller a major overhaul with a significant redesign of the exterior and interior, more features, enhanced safety and a new turbo petrol powertrain.

time-read
2 mins  |
April 01, 2024