Mariah After Midnight
New York magazine|August 31–September 13, 2020
Thirty years into an epic career, Mariah Carey is still trying to explain herself.
By Allison P. Davis. Photographs by Dana Scruggs
Mariah After Midnight

MARIAH CAREY LOVES CHRISTMAS. She loves it with a fanatic’s strict adherence to the laws of Christmas joy. She loves it like no one has ever loved Christmas before. (Did you have an actual reindeer at your holiday festivities last year? Did you hang out with Santa? Didn’t think so.) Christmas is also a cornerstone of the Carey complex. Frank Sinatra might have made the holiday classically jolly, Sufjan Stevens might have made it indie whiny, and Ariana Grande might have made it horny, but no artist has come to define our commercially driven holiday fantasies more than Carey has with “All I Want for Christmas Is You.” Since the song dropped on her 1994 holiday album, it’s made an estimated $60 million-plus in royalties. It’s stayed relevant, thanks to fans, of course; a cover on the 2003 Love Actually soundtrack; an album reissue; an annual “All I Want for Christmas Is You” holiday-concert series that sold out a show at Madison Square Garden last year; an animated film; an Amazon Music mini-doc about the undying meaning of the song; and streams on streams on streams. Last year, it finally hit No. 1 on “The Hot 100” chart, after a record-breaking (for its slowness) 25-year journey. Who cares how long it took? It’s her 19th No. 1 hit—putting her above Elvis and one away from tying the Beatles. Does it matter if you like the song? (Full disclosure: I don’t.) No! It is the omnipresent anthem of holiday happiness.

This story is from the August 31–September 13, 2020 edition of New York magazine.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.

This story is from the August 31–September 13, 2020 edition of New York magazine.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.

MORE STORIES FROM NEW YORK MAGAZINEView All
Indecent Exposure
New York magazine

Indecent Exposure

Jerrod Carmichael's reality series attempts to excavate his deepest flaws.

time-read
5 mins  |
April 8-21, 2024
Grave Mysteries
New York magazine

Grave Mysteries

Josh O'Connor searches for the afterlife as a sad-eyed tomb raider.

time-read
2 mins  |
April 8-21, 2024
Not Her First Rodeo
New York magazine

Not Her First Rodeo

Beyoncé's country album is a history lesson, a rallying cry, and a missed opportunity.

time-read
5 mins  |
April 8-21, 2024
How'd You Make That?
New York magazine

How'd You Make That?

Three masterpieces, from glimmer through struggle to breakthrough.

time-read
10+ mins  |
April 8-21, 2024
In the Belly of the Barbz
New York magazine

In the Belly of the Barbz

Fear them. Cheer them. Nicki Minaj fans are sticking by their queen.

time-read
6 mins  |
April 8-21, 2024
At the Altar of Korean Fried Chicken
New York magazine

At the Altar of Korean Fried Chicken

Coqodaq's owner calls it a cathedral. It feels more like a club.

time-read
3 mins  |
April 8-21, 2024
WHO ATE WHERE
New York magazine

WHO ATE WHERE

119 YEARS of PUNK BREAKFASTS, UPTOWN LUNCHES, DRUNKEN DEALMAKING, and IMPOSSIBLE RESERVATIONS

time-read
9 mins  |
April 8-21, 2024
Arizona's Split Reality
New York magazine

Arizona's Split Reality

Ground zero for the rigged-election conspiracy, the border state could decide both the fate of the Senate and the presidency.

time-read
10+ mins  |
April 8-21, 2024
98 MINUTES WITH...The Lavery Family
New York magazine

98 MINUTES WITH...The Lavery Family

Beloved literary couple Daniel and Grace Lavery and their partner, Lily Woodruff, are all living and working full time in their Brooklyn apartment. Now, they have to find space for a baby.

time-read
6 mins  |
April 8-21, 2024
Neighborhood News: Patrolling With the Rat Czar
New York magazine

Neighborhood News: Patrolling With the Rat Czar

On a smokeout with Vermin Enemy No. 1.

time-read
1 min  |
April 8-21, 2024