No matter what the market conditions are, investors are always faced with this peculiar dilemma of whether to adopt a buy and hold (forever) strategy or to exit stocks at regular intervals. Most so-called longterm investors adopt a buy and hold strategy and never sell shares even when the stocks have either multiplied or have fallen by more than 50 to 80 per cent. This is because the buy and hold temperament does not allow such investors to book early profit or loss. Thus, the perennial question is always about which option provides more returns. In other words, which strategy proves to be better in the long term: buy and hold or exit?
The answer to this question may not be objective. However, when we have a look at historical data and study how several investors have been stuck with underperforming stocks even after holding them for more than five years, we can say that there is a serious case for investors to consider adopting an exit strategy, either at the stock or the portfolio level.
Assuming a long-term investor adopts a buy and hold strategy and focuses on BSE 500 stocks as an investment basket, there is a good chance that he or she may have been stuck (negative returns) with at least 19 stocks (which made all-time highs in 2010) out of BSE 500 stocks even after remaining invested since 2010 till now i.e. April 2020. In other words, at least 19 stocks which were trending in 2010 and were bought by long-term investors adopting a buy and hold strategy did not manage to generate positive returns in spite of holding them for more than nine years!
This story is from the April 27, 2020 edition of Dalal Street Investment Journal.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the April 27, 2020 edition of Dalal Street Investment Journal.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
Does AUM Size Matter?
Investors generally focus on a fund's past returns. They think that a larger fund is better. On the flip side, some investors raise concerns about whether a fund can sustain its strong performance after growing to a substantial size. What is the reality? Rakesh Deshmukh takes a closer look at the scenario
Base Rate Investing: The Smart Investor's Secret
Base rate investing offers a distinct advantage to investors encouraging them to look beyond the noise and focus on underlying fundamentals and longterm trends. The article explains how by understanding and applying this strategy effectively, you can make informed investment decisions and potentially outperform the market over time
Back To The 'All is Well' Feeling
Domestic indices hit record highs on the back of robust performance in real estate, power, metals and automotive sectors
Should Commodity Funds Be Part Of Your Portfolio?
Commodities serve as tangible assets that offer investors a means to engage with the real economy and provide a degree of insulation from financial system disruptions. In this scenario, multi-asset allocation funds represent a more efficient vehicle for commodity exposure compared to hybrid schemes. Here are the details
Asset Allocation & Diversification
Remember, when you diversify your investments, you minimise the chances of suffering from what is known as 'single security risk', or the risk that your investment will fluctuate widely in value with the price of one holding.
Ten Commandments of Wealth Creation
Financial Planning
Gold Glitters Amid a Narrow Range Trading
Over the last two weeks, the commodities market displayed cautious activity with investors trading within narrow margins, eagerly awaiting pivotal economic data and insights from Federal Reserve officials.
Can Global Equities Sustain the February Momentum?
Even though the markets touched new highs in February, they did experience some challenges, notably in the bond sector, which faced difficulties due to an uptick in interest rates.
"Future outlook of railways and railway wagons industry appears promising"
Umesh Chowdhary Vice Chairman & Managing Director Titagarh Rail Systems Limited
Metals and Mining: Poised For A Steely Performance
While investors were drawn to the impressive rally in metal stocks, the recent interim budget indirectly bolstered the metals industry with substantial announcements in infrastructure, real estate, defence and railway sectors, which are known for their extensive use of metals. Mandar Wagh explores the future prospects of the industry, analysing financial performance, risks and growth triggers