In November, chief justice of India D.Y. Chandrachud delivered a speech at his alma mater Harvard Law School. During the event, a member of the audience raised a query regarding the recent selection of lawyer Victoria Gowri as an additional judge of the Madras High Court by the Supreme Court collegium. The question was about the allegation that she had engaged in hate speech and was perceived to be close to the Bharatiya Janata Party.
Chandrachud’s response, perceived by many as evasive, involved explaining the functioning of the Indian collegium system to a Western audience. He argued that a lawyer’s personal biases or actions before becoming a judge should not weigh heavily on the collegium, emphasising that India’s judicial system mandates and expects non-partisanship and adherence to constitutional values once a judge takes oath.
It is not coincidental that a question on hate speech was put to Chandrachud in a Western setting. The question could not have been put to his predecessors at the apex court.
Chief Justice’s Court
Historically, the Supreme Court of India, as a custodian of a progressive constitution, has had a liberal constituency both within and outside the country. So does Chandrachud, something that could not be said with clarity and conviction about his many predecessors.
The character of the Supreme Court often changes as a new incumbent takes over as the chief justice. It was believed that with Chandrachud at the helm, the court would acquire the character that the constitution trusted it with, that it would become the same old robust institution that it was meant to be as a branch of democracy which holds the executive accountable.
Esta historia es de la edición December 2023 de Outlook Business.
Comience su prueba gratuita de Magzter GOLD de 7 días para acceder a miles de historias premium seleccionadas y a más de 8500 revistas y periódicos.
Ya eres suscriptor ? Conectar
Esta historia es de la edición December 2023 de Outlook Business.
Comience su prueba gratuita de Magzter GOLD de 7 días para acceder a miles de historias premium seleccionadas y a más de 8500 revistas y periódicos.
Ya eres suscriptor? Conectar
The Faultline Called Unemployment
With youths accounting for a staggering majority of the unemployed population in India, the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party, which claims to have put India on a sound growth track, has some tough questions to answer as it seeks a third term at the Centre
'TECH, GOVERNMENT SUPPORT DRIVING GROWTH IN INDIA'S EXPORTS'
As overall exports in India witnessed a rise over the previous year, Akshay Ghulati, co-founder of Strategy and Global Expansion at Shiprocket Global, talks about five drivers of booming trade in India
IN THE RIGHT ENSEMBLE
Manish Kapoor MD and CEO of global clothing brand Pepe Jeans London, finds happiness in spending time with his family and bonding with them over leisure trips, Formula One races, cricket matches and cooking
GREEN GLOBETROTTING
Amid growing awareness about sustainable tourism, more people are hoping to reduce their carbon footprint. Besides benefitting the planet, sustainable tourism also presents the industry with the opportunity to grow responsibly
LOOPM ALTERNATIVES: ADDING A NEW AND LASTING DIMENSION TO PRESERVING FOOD
LoopFresh, an Indian innovation promises to transform the way perishables are stored on our supermarket shelves to retain their freshness.
PLANET VS PLASTIC OR PLASTIC VS SUBSTITUTES?
The theme of Earth Day 2024 was Planet vs Plastic, but plastic industry stakeholders are armed with studies to find faults with its alternatives
WELSPUN LIVING LIMITED: MAKING STRIDES TOWARDS GREENER FUTURE
Striving to advance systematically on the path of sustainable development, Welspun, a global leader in home solutions, is making a mark with its holistic Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) approach towards well-being of all the stakeholders
PROMOTING BIOFUELS FOR SUSTAINABLE ENERGY SUPPLY
Biofuels offer a viable solution to reducing dependence on imported fossil fuel while providing cleaner energy, states Kishan Karunakaran, CEO of Buyofuel. In an interview he speaks about how agro-waste and even plastics and tyres can be utilised for producing biofuels, thus supporting a circular economy.
A Ready Reckoner for Climate Justice
In Climate Change: The Policy, Law, and Practice, Jatinder Cheema presents a comprehensive exploration of the multifaceted challenges posed by climate change and the corresponding policy, legal and practical responses needed to address this global crisis effectively
TETRA PAK'S AMBITION TO LEAD THE SUSTAINABILITY TRANSFORMATION
Tetra Pak has set 2030 net zero emission goals for itself and 2050 net Zero emission goals for its supply chain. Juhi Gupta, Director Sustainability Tetra Pak, South Asia, in an interview shares how this is being achieved. Excerpts: