A TITLE reallocated, questions on some qualifications and a judge dismissed after 37 years: the British Show Horse Association (BSHA) Rising Star series has sparked debate.
The lightweight cob title awarded at the London International (LIHS) has been reallocated. H&H has heard concerns over the amateur status of some others at the final, but the BSHA said all concerns about the Rising Star classes have "now been investigated thoroughly".
H&H reported in 2022 that the new series focused on, the BSHA said, "encouraging more to join in and have a go".
But Alan Mickleburgh, the BSHA judge dismissed, thinks it will have the opposite effect.
"All this misrepresentation is going to put them off," he told H&H.
Mr Mickleburgh said he was to judge his first series qualifiers last spring, and that despite his experience, he never went to a show without a rulebook. He said he asked BSHA general manager Lucy Savill for a rulebook, then and at the semi-final, and was told none had been printed.
Mr Mickleburgh judged the hack semi-final qualifier, in which there were two riders. He thought Finn Williamson's ride Port Lou Lou was very nice, but not a hack.
"Ian Smeeth, who's on the BSHA board and chair of judges, was at the side of the ring and I commented to him that it was a shame; the horse is more a riding horse - and he agreed. I asked if there was provision in the rules for him to move to the small riding horse final and he said, 'Yes'.
"The competitor thought having come second, he wouldn't qualify but I told him he'd qualified for the small riding horse final. I didn't think there was anything wrong with it as no rules were available on the day, and I'd had permission from a board member."
At London, Mr Smeeth judged the small riding horse final, which Port Lou Lou won.
This story is from the February 08, 2024 edition of Horse & Hound.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the February 08, 2024 edition of Horse & Hound.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
'He's barely out of the county...'
Minutes into a trip abroad, Adam’s superstitions are realised when things go awry on the farm. It’s all hands to the grindstone, proving that there's never a dull moment for Tessa Waugh
The last Edwardian sportsman
Sporting paintings by Raoul Millais, whose life spanned the 20th century, are hanging in hunting homes all over the country. Liam Clancytells us about the artist and his life well travelled
Gangster steals the show
The area trial is won by a combination on their first attempt at this level anda daughter of clone Murka’s Gem shines bright
Charlotte's clean sweep
Olympic hopefuls in action while Natasha Baker makes a winning return and Carl debuts his latest superstar
Woodward is a class act
A complex character rewards his rider’s patience with a third international win, while a 17-year-old makes her mark
Student has the Upper hand
A former showjumper and an osteopath take top spots, while a corner question causes cross-country problems
All change
The leaderboard tips upside down, as the top two plummet and Caroline Powell rises to triumph
A super day
Eric Winter’s track provides a brilliant cross-country day, with Irish first-timer Lucy Latta delivering the outstanding performance
Spooky 'Isaac' holds it together
The defending champion pilots a rising star to lead the first phase
'We all hate doing anything badly'
As part of H€SH’s 140th anniversary this year, we are celebrating Britain’s great horsey families with a series of interviews. In our third instalment, we speak to the multi-garlanded showing dynasty of David Tatlow, his daughter Loraine Homer and her daughter Alice