DRESSAGE judges are being asked to do the “impossible”, as they are predisposed to give higher marks to those who share their nationality and have previously performed well.
A study by Inga Wolframm, professor of sustainable equestrianism at Van Hall Larenstein University of Applied Sciences, considered whether the information a judge must evaluate could exceed what can reasonably be expected, so if the system predisposes them to bias, or cognitive shortcuts, that favour certain combinations.
She analysed more than 500 scores from CDI5*s in 2022 and 2023. She found judges are predisposed to give higher scores to riders who share their nationality, and combinations who had previously performed well, indicated by FEI rank and starting order.
“These form what may be referred to as a bias cascade, which is likely to lead to inadvertent, yet unfair, advantages for certain riders,” Dr Wolframm wrote.
She told H&H she is not blaming individuals; judges are not at fault “unless you fault them for being human”.
This story is from the January 05, 2024 edition of Horse & Hound.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the January 05, 2024 edition of Horse & Hound.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
Jappeloup
A small horse who looked like two halves put together’, Jappeloup nonetheless proved to have a big heart and a huge talent”.
Collett takes two
A bumper fixture hosts 12 intermediate and open intermediate sections, as Paris contenders blow away the cobwebs
Capitalise on buyers' remorse
Equestrian properties might be in short supply, but prices are back to normal after the Covid frenzy as the capital lures buyers again
Games making
Equestrianism will be in the thick of the action in Paris, but the logistics of hosting Olympics in the heart of an iconic city are a challenge. Kate Johnson asks organisers, riders and grooms for their memories of urban Olympic sites
On the bench
Being picked as the \"fourth man\" to support a three-man Olympic team, ready to step in at any moment in the competition, requires a resilient and unflinchingly sportsmanlike mindset.
A brush with the Games
Want to know what really goes into preparing an Olympic campaign? Bethany Stone speaks to top industry grooms with star-studded CVs for the scoop
One moment in time
The Olympics is the zenith of an athlete's career but precious few scale those giddy heights. Sue Polley asks four British Olympians about their most memorable experiences
'Pride? I just felt relief
Blyth Tait on jumping barn roofs, \"freezing\" in the Atlanta heat and the day his eight-year-old prodigy won Olympic gold
Mental health advocate
Harry Dunlop retired from training in 2022, having held his licence for 16 years. He founded the Trainer Support Network in 2023
Hugo Simon
The six-time Olympian tells Bernard Bale about his \"extraterrestrial\" string of horses, changing nationality and his success at the boycotted Games