The Kingfisher Airlines fiasco has put a question mark on methodologies used to value brands. It also has a lot of lessons for brand valuation companies.
Accounting firm Grant Thornton valued brand Kingfisher Airlines (KFA) at `4,100 crore in 2008. With 32 per cent-plus market share then, KFA was the undisputed leader. Its owner, Vijay Mallya, pampered flyers with inflight entertainment and exotic food, which cost crores. The airline made losses all through except in 2010/11, when it made a small profit. Worse, Mallya bought lossmaking Air Deccan. KFA went bust in 2012. So, what went wrong?
Branding gurus say Mallya took rules that had worked for him in the FMCG sector and applied them to his airline. This misfired. In FMCG, growing by spending heavily on advertising and acquiring market share through acquisitions is the norm. Mallya, however, acquired bankruptcy when he bought Air Deccan.
KFA had borrowed over `9,000 crore from banks. Creditors are trying to recover some money by selling the brand. It is, obviously, extinct, and doesn’t have takers, despite the fact that the trademarks ‘King of Good Times’ and ‘Fly Kingfisher’ could have fitted into the branding strategy of any existing or start-up airline. “The controversy surrounding Kingfisher may have damaged the brand, so no airline has come forward,” says Aaron Keller, Managing Principal of US-based brand consultancy Capsule. The creditors have taken Grant Thornton to court, questioning the basis on which it assigned the brand such a value.
The episode has put a question mark on the working of brand valuation companies which, say experts,must update their models according to fast-changing market realities. Banks, too, have to learn.
This story is from the April 10, 2016 edition of Business Today.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the April 10, 2016 edition of Business Today.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
All That Glitters
The price of gold has been rising unabated. It has soared to more than 73,000 per 10 gm in 2024 from *31,000 in early 2018. Is the rally sustainable or is this a bubble?
"Hire for attitude, not ability"
Thryve Digital is a player in the healthcare technology sector delivering next-generation solutions
Road Warrior
For Khalid Wani, Senior Director of Sales at Western Digital India, life is much more than just the corner office. Biking across the world is one way he derives meaning for his life
WIDENING THE POOL
THERE HAS BEEN A JUMP IN INDIVIDUALS INVESTING DIRECTLY IN THE STOCK MARKETS, BUT MUMBAI AND AHMEDABAD STILL ACCOUNT FOR THE LION'S SHARE. THERE DEFINITELY IS SCOPE FOR IMPROVEMENT IN TERMS OF PENETRATION LEVELS ACROSS THE COUNTRY
CRISIS IN THE CLOUDS
INDIAN AVIATION IS IN CRISIS. AIRLINES ARE GRAPPLING WITH FLIGHT CANCELLATIONS, CREW SHORTAGES, AND COMPLAINTS ABOUT POOR SERVICE, ARE BLEEDING DUE TO RISING COSTS WILL THE FASTEST-GROWING AVIATION MARKET RECOVER?
"India should start privatising public sector banks"
Arvind Panagariya, Chairman of the 16th Finance Commission, on growth, inequality, jobs, the banking sector, and more
THE DARK SIDE OF GOLD LOANS
THERE HAS BEEN A SHARP RISE IN GOLD LOANS IN RECENT YEARS. BUT THERE IS A SEEDIER SIDE TO THIS, AS IS EVIDENT FROM THE RED FLAG THE RBI RAISED RECENTLY. WILL THE REGULATOR'S MOVE PROTECT CUSTOMERS?
"I LET MY WORK DO THE TALKING"
Megha Engineering & Infrastructures MD P.V. Krishna Reddy on being low profile, the infra opportunity and much more
"Core of insurance lies in long-term security"
Vibha Padalkar, MD & CEO of HDFC Life, on the insurance provider's performance, surrender charges, and future innovations
Distress in the Books
Bandhan Bank, the brainchild of Chandra Shekhar Ghosh, has made the journey from an MFI to a bank, but with many hurdles. Now with his resignation as MD & CEO, is the lender staring at more uncertainty?